In 2024, students in Years 5 and 6 will think for themselves and discuss the following topics:
A fair society
Do societies have a responsibility to make sure everyone has a real opportunity to go to school and receive healthcare? What are some of the challenges involved in creating such opportunities? And do societies have a responsibility to address inequalities that are the result of good or bad luck?
Appeal to authority
When should we simply accept a rule or a piece of advice from someone who is an expert or authority (for example, a teacher, doctor, the government, an older brother or sister or a friend)? When, if ever, is it okay to challenge a rule or piece of advice given by someone who is an expert or authority?
Extending human rights to animals
What rights do all humans have? The right to an education? The right to internet access? The right to free speech? And should any of these rights be granted to other animals – like chimpanzees?
Beliefs, opinions, tolerance and respect
People have all sorts of beliefs and opinions – about things like smoking, politicians, the moon landing, aliens, ethics and so on. Are people always entitled to their beliefs? Should we always tolerate their beliefs? Should we respect their beliefs? And should we always allow people to publish their beliefs? What if they’re harmful and they want to publish them in a school newsletter?
Interacting with AI
As artificial intelligence (AI) technologies like ChatBots, search engines, and personalised recommendations become ever-present in students’ lives, it’s valuable for them to reflect on how they engage with such technologies. Some of the big questions students consider in this topic include: How are artificial intelligence different from and similar to human intelligence? Is it wrong to be cruel to artificial intelligence? Is it okay to use artificial intelligence to help with schoolwork? Can we trust the information provided by artificial intelligence?
Teasing
What sorts of things count as teasing? Is there such thing as harmless teasing? And is teasing ever okay?
Drugs in sport Athletes do lots of different things to get an advantage, but what counts as an unfair advantage in sport? Loading up on carbohydrates before a race? Drinking coffee? Training at special high-altitude camps? Wearing a special swimsuit? Taking performance-enhancing drugs?
Fatalism
Are our futures and fates fixed? Does what we do today affect what happens in the future? And if the future is fated – if we cannot avoid our fates – can we be held morally responsible for what we do? Is there any point in trying to do good things if the future will happen regardless of what we do?
Moral responsibility
The universe is often thought to be governed by cause- and-effect. But if we ourselves are products of cause-and-effect (that is, our actions are the result of how we were raised and other factors), then can we be held morally responsible for anything we do?
Thinking
What is a thought? Do you ever think about your own thinking? Do you think in words or pictures or feelings? Is it possible to stop thinking? What are memories?
Should we take circumstances into account?
Is it always wrong to do certain things – like lying or breaking a promise – or do the circumstances matter? And do cultural circumstances matter? Is it wrong for some cultures to do something – like eat whales – but not for others?
Are some things just wrong?
How important is it to have consistent moral values? Are some things just wrong (regardless of whether some cultures think they’re okay)? If so, how can we tell what’s right or wrong in a way that’s independent of culture?
In 2025, students in Years 5 and 6 will discuss and think for themselves about the following topics:
Voting
Is it okay to vote for someone just because they’re your friend? How should we balance self-interest and the needs of others when choosing who to vote for? For example, is it okay to vote for someone whose policies would benefit you but are not in the best interests of everyone? Should voting be compulsory or voluntary? And should voters be well informed? Or should everyone be allowed to vote, regardless of how much thought they’ve put into their vote?
Punishment
What is the point of punishment? Is punishment necessary to stop people from doing the wrong thing? Should people who do the wrong thing be made to ‘pay’ or make up for what they’ve done? Do punishments help restore order or ‘balance’ to the world?
Being vain
Is it okay to want to look good? And is it okay to want to look better than other people? What does it mean to be vain? And is there anything wrong with being vain? Can one person’s vanity impact the wellbeing of others? Where do we draw the line between reasonable and excessive concern for how we appear to others?
The structure of arguments
This topic is a chance for students to practice forming and evaluating arguments, including checking whether the conclusion makes sense, identifying any unstated assumptions and checking that the claims on which the argument rests are true.
How far does our moral responsibility extend?
How do we balance the needs of our friends, family and community against the needs of others? How do you decide who to donate money to? Is it more important to donate to local causes? Do we have a moral responsibility to future generations – to people who haven’t even been born yet?
Stealing
What sorts of things count as stealing? Does watching a fireworks display without paying count as stealing? What, if anything, makes stealing wrong? Is it the fact that it is illegal? What’s the relationship between the law and morality? If stealing is wrong, is it always wrong?
Jumping to conclusions
We often use reasoning to draw conclusions from ‘all’ and ‘only’ statements. For example, if I knew that all planets revolve around the sun and that Mars is a planet, then I can reason that Mars revolves around the sun. But people often jump to conclusions that aren’t justified by reversing the direction of the argument. For example, if I knew all planets revolve around the sun and that Eris orbited the sun, I might falsely conclude that Eris is a planet. This topic is a chance for students to practice different reasoning strategies using ‘all’ and ‘only’ statements and reflect on some common mistakes people make when reasoning.
Homelessness in Australia
What are some of the main causes of homelessness in Australia? And what are some common misconceptions about homelessness? Do we as individuals and as a society have a responsibility to help the homeless?
Killing animals for food
Is it okay to kill and eat animals? What are some of the common arguments for and against eating meat? What about sustainably sourced or free-range meat – is that okay to eat? And what about lab-grown meat – is that okay to eat?
Why should we trust science?
Do our beliefs matter? Does it matter if I believe in superheroes or that eating rhino horns can cure cancer? In the latter case, rhino killings have increased markedly, threatening the species' survival. If someone believes that eating rhino horns can cure cancer but has very little scientific knowledge, can they be blamed for this outcome? Is it important that people understand science or trust scientists?
Fairness
Should teachers spend the same amount of time with every student? Or should they help some students more than others? Does being fair mean treating everyone exactly the same? Or does it mean treating people differently based on the circumstances?